Fontes Living LibraryAN INITIATIVE OF FONTES ACADEMY

CHARLOTTE MASON · BOOK 1: SELF-KNOWLEDGE · CHAPTER 13

The Beauty Sense

Read the original slowly. The shaded interruptions and end-of-chapter discussion are Fontes companions, separate from Mason’s words.

THE ORIGINAL 1905 TEXT · CHARLOTTE MASON

The Dæmon of Exclusiveness.—The Beauty Sense adds so much to the joy of life that it is not easy to see what danger attends it. But, perhaps, Exclusiveness is the Dæmon that waits on a too keen sense of the joy of Beauty, whether in music, painting, one’s own surroundings, or even in natural scenery. Exclusiveness gets the ear of the Prime Minister and convinces him that the joys of Beauty are so full and satisfying that nothing else is necessary to complete the happiness of life. In vain does Intellect invite to new fields of research; in vain does good and necessary work present itself; in vain are duties clamorous. The person who is given up to the intoxication of Beauty conceives that Beauty and Goodness are one and the same thing, and that Duty is no more than seeking one’s own pleasure in the ways one best likes. People, too, become excluded.

poplar trees and a sunlit garden
Poplars, Eragny, Camille Pissarro · The Metropolitan Museum of Art. Public domain. Look for a visual detail that changes how you read this chapter.

We may not Choose our Lives.—Instead of accepting the relations, friends, and neighbours that God sends us in the course of our lives, the devotee of Beauty chooses for himself, and cares to know only those people whose views of life are the same as his own. So with regard to places, he cannot tolerate for a moment things which are unsightly and unlovely, so he does not go where working people and poor people have to live. In the end, he misses the happiness to which the Beauty Sense was meant to minister. For happiness comes of effort, service, wide interests, and, last and least, of enjoyment; and when people put enjoyment, even of beautiful things, in the first place (and indeed in place of all else), they miss the very thing they seek, and become enfeebled in body and fretful and discontented in temper.

A Paradise of Pleasure.—But we need not let fear of evil keep us out of that paradise of pleasure which the Beauty Sense is meant to open for us all. Of two things we must take heed. In the first place, we must not let any better-than-my-neighbour notions get into our heads; and in the next, we must make it our business, as much as in us lies, to bring Beauty to places where it is not. Bearing these two cautions in mind, the Dæmon of Exclusiveness need have no terror for us.

Chapter prose follows the public-domain transcription of the 1905 second edition. Compare the original scan. Footnote numbers open their notes in the transcription. Page markers are omitted; the chapter prose is unabridged.

AFTER THE READING · FONTES BOOK CLUB

Carry the conversation further.

01 · Begin with the words

What does Mason actually claim?

Find a sentence that complicates or sharpens your first answer to “Why might love of beauty become narrow?” Read it aloud. Which word bears the weight of her argument?

02 · Test the idea

Where does the image help?

Mason calls exclusiveness a danger to the beauty sense. Appreciation can widen with patient looking. Can you imagine a case that makes this idea harder? Which part is observation, which is analogy, and which is Mason’s belief?

03 · Bring another reader

Ask before answering.

What would a thoughtful person who disagrees with Mason say? Give their best reason fairly. Then offer a careful response from the text.

In your paper book journal

Narrate and draw

Study two unlike objects or artworks. Sketch a line from each and write what each gives your attention.

Write a full narration in your own words. Quote only a short phrase you want to remember and mark it as Mason’s.

A practice away from the screen

Notice, make, or try

Visit a window, garden, or gallery and linger before something you would normally pass by.

Private reflection may stay private. A small drawing, list, prayer, conversation, or experiment can be enough.